what is best practice to use review to manage comments and changes?
I create video and upload it to Camtasia review. Reviewers leave change request comments. I incorporate changes and upload version 2 for review. None of the comments from v1 are carried forward so it is not easy for reviewers to check changes. This seems to me a flaw in Camtasia review. The workaround is for reviewers to switch between versions to check their original comments and time stamp. Definitely not convenient or user friendly. Any suggestions for a best practice to handle this? I suppose i can copy all comments and time stamps into email --not convenient. Looking for a better way.
-
You're right that you can switch between versions at the top, and that the comments are intentionally segregated between versions. The reason for this was that the comments only apply to the version that they were commented on, and more, that the time stamps only apply to that version. That is, you may make a v2 that is longer, or shorter, than the first version and there isn't really a way for Video Review to know where that time was inserted to offset the comments.
However, it's really interesting to hear about your use case!
I can see how your reviewers are interested in verifying that their feedback was incorporated. Am I understanding correctly that they'd like to somehow be able to look back through the comments/reviews that they made on the previous version and check off or verify that each of the items have been addressed to their satisfaction?
0 -
Paul,
Thank you for your thoughtful reply.
Yes, the concern is about how reviewers can identify and verify the incorporation of their change requests --in a more simplified manner than switching between versions.
I see your point about time stamp alteration in a revision.
Interesting problem. I hope Camtasia team will put on their thinking caps for this one and solve my concern.
0
Vous devez vous connecter pour laisser un commentaire.
Commentaires
2 commentaires